Sunday, March 17, 2013

Final draft of Action Research Plan

Here is my final draft of my plan, I made one change by adding a classroom management component.  Let me know what you think.  Thanks!


Same Sex Classes Action Research Plan
Goal:  The goal of this action research project is to determine if same sex classes improve the academic success of high school math students.
Action Step (s)
Person(s) Responsible
Timeline:  Start/End
Needed Resources
Evaluation
Survey students on thoughts about same sex math class vs. heterogeneous core classes
Jamie Baldwin
April 2013
Surveys
Have each student complete a survey and explain how same sex class is beneficial to academic success.
Collect data from math unit tests from each class
Jamie Baldwin
April 2013
Excel,
Math unit test scores
Analyze data and gather in an Excel workbook
Research the success rates of same sex classes
Jamie Baldwin
April 2013
Internet, scholarly journals
Research instructional strategies and analyze why same sex classrooms are successful.
Research Classroom management techniques for same sex classes
Jamie Baldwin
April 2013
Internet, scholarly journals
Teaching a class full of males can present classroom management issues that will hinder academic achievement and therefore policies and procedures need to be in place to prevent misbehavior.
Collect TAKS data for current math students
Jamie Baldwin
May 2013
Excel
TAKS Data,
Eduphoria
Analyze TAKS scores and gather in an Excel worksheet
Compare math unit exams and TAKS scores from 2011 – 2012 heterogeneous classes to 2012 -2013 same sex classes
Jamie Baldwin
May 2013
Excel,
Math unit test scores, TAKS Data
Analyze 2011-12 data and 2012-13 data and gather in an Excel worksheet
Create data tables/ graphs comparing 2011-12 test data to 2012-13 test data
Jamie Baldwin
May 2013
Excel, Test data
Create presentation on why same sex classes are successful
Present findings to Principal, Associate principal, and assistant principals
Jamie Baldwin
June 2013
Power Point
Explain to principals that same sex classes are successful and should be implemented in other core subjects.


Examining the work: Setting the foundation
Students often find themselves easily distracted in math class.  In a subject that is plagued with disgust, teachers struggle to help students comprehend and understand complex and abstract math concepts.  One of the biggest distractors in a classroom is the opposite sex.  By splitting classes by gender, teachers can explore instructional strategies that are successful for males and females.  Although students may be alarmed at first, they will enjoy having the opposite sex removed because they no longer will feel the peer pressure of appealing to the opposite sex.
Analyzing data
I will analyze Math models unit tests and TAKS scores from 2012 -13 school year.  My math models classes are currently split by gender.  I will compare the 2012 – 13 data of same sex classes to the 2011 – 12 data of heterogeneous classes.  I will look at passing standards and passing rates.  I will also analyze if males or females perform better on specific unit tests, benchmarks, and the TAKS test.
Developing deeper understanding
I will survey my current math models students about what they believe to be the pros and cons of same sex classes.  I will also have them describe the pros and cons of their heterogeneous classes.  They will reflect on previous math classes and describe which setting was more conducive to academic achievement, same sex math class or heterogeneous math class.  Along with looking at surveys, I will research classroom management strategies for male classes.  Males are traditionally rowdier than females and may need additional techniques to ensure academic success.
Engaging in Self-Reflection
After analyzing the Math Models unit tests and TAKS scores for 2011 – 12 and 2012 – 13 school years, I will talk with other math teachers and my site supervisor about my findings.  I will reflect over what I have learned and the successfulness of my same sex classes.  My reflection may prompt more questions: Do males or females benefit more academically from same sex classes?  Would same sex classes be beneficial in science, social studies and English?  Would same sex classes be beneficial in raising STARR scores?  Would same sex classes be more beneficial in freshman and sophomore classes vs. junior and senior classes?
Exploring Programmatic Patterns
After I analyze my test data, consult with other teachers and principals, and reflect over my findings, I will need to further investigate some of the problems associated with splitting males and females.  The first issue to address would be classroom management in male classes.  Professional development would need to be offered for gender split classes especially the classroom management component.  Next, I will discuss the pros and cons of same sex classes with math teachers and principals.  I would also like to explore the pros and cons of expanding same sex classes to other grade levels and other core subjects.  Lastly, we would also have to consider which type or students would benefit the most and the least from same sex classes. 
Determining direction
After examining problem areas, I would work with my site supervisor to determine if same sex classes could be implemented in other math classes along with science classes.  Although I believe all core classes would benefit from same sex classes, we would target science next because it is the most similar subject to math and the next hardest subject for the average student.  We would work with a select group of teachers who would be interested and capable of handling same sex classes. 
Taking action for school improvement
Once my site supervisor and I have found the math and science teachers that are willing to teach same sex classes, we would all work with the principal on determining what math and science classes would be separated by gender.  Our main focus will be improving test scores for struggling math and science students.  We will compare heterogeneous unit tests to same sex unit test data and analyze success rates and trend data.  We will also explore teaching strategies that ensure success for males and strategies that ensure success for females.  We will implement these strategies and techniques into our classrooms and monitor the progress and achievement of the students.
Sustaining improvement
Upon the conclusion of the 2013 – 2014 school year, the same sex teaching core and principals will evaluate the success and struggles for the year.  We will survey the students about the pros and cons of the same sex math and science class.  We will solicit their suggestions on what they feel needs to be improved and what they enjoyed about the classes.  The gender split class committee will brainstorm changes for the next year and determine if the same math and science subjects will be split by gender.  The committee will also analyze the student surveys and make appropriate changes as needed.  We will decide if more gender split classes need to be added for the following school year.  We will also analyze the success rates of the teaching strategies and learning techniques that were implemented.  We will determine if the strategies will be continued the next year or if they need to be altered. 

23 comments:

  1. Jamie,

    Great idea and plan! I find this extremely interesting and I cannot wait to read your results.

    Something someone told me and now I am going to share with you. You could possible share your findings with your entire staff. I strongly think they will find your results very interesting as well.

    Great job and good luck!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm very intrigued to see how this plays out! Cannot wait for the results!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This something I wonder about as a middle school teacher. I think that my students would perform better if they were separated by sex. Please share your results on your blog.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, I'm sure middle school students would benefit from same sex classes especially with them going through puberty.

      Delete
  4. Great plan! I agree with Jamie, your research should be shared with your staff. I think this should produce some interesting and valuable results.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, I'm already seeing some interesting results.

      Delete
  5. Hey Jamie!! Small world huh?? I was looking up different people to follow their blogs and saw your pic!!! I don't think my blogger profile has a pic but my google+ pic is a photo of me and Lauren Anderson. What city are you teaching in? I teach in a little town near San Antonio.

    Your action research plan sounds super interesting. I think that your results will show that kids will be more focused in same-sex classroom. Just my personal opinion though! Good Luck!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Jessica, it is a small world. How are you? I'm teaching at a school outside of Houston called Manvel High School. Thanks for commenting on my blog. I did see your pic with Lauren, yall look really cute.

      Delete
  6. As a middle school teacher myself I agree with the same sex classroom. I think it will allow the children to be more focused on the task at hand!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Your plan looks ready to go. However, you could include faculty and other members of the school when presenting your findings. Great job and keep up the good work!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, I did not think about sharing it with faculty.

      Delete
  8. I am confused about whether your plan is for the current year or for 2013-2014. Either way, this is the most unique topic I have seen!

    http://educationalinquirer2013.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I currently have same sex classes so my research is for this year. I taught heterogeneous classes last year and will compare the data. I'm trying to help my site supervisor/ assistant principal convince the associate principal to have same sex classes in other math and science classes. Thank you for commenting.

      Delete
  9. One of my questions is the research more geared toward same sex female classes or males. I mentioned in a discussion post that my school has a lot of girl on girl dating and bullying. So does the distraction of males turn to girl distraction and would it be surveyed the same and grouped into dating and a social distraction in the classroom. My other question is does it matter who teaches the students, a male teacher teaching all females or a female teacher. Also we have openly gay teachers so how should teachers behave in front of students when they have a same sex attraction, or does it matter from a parental or peer teacher opinion. I am not bias and work with openly gay students on a daily basis because of the problems they have.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am looking at the success rates for both sexes. My girls for the most part get along great. I have had only 2 incidents occur. The first was with my all boys class were a gay male was being picked on by the other males. Once it was brought to my attention I had a stern talk with the class, then kept the boys involved after class and talked with them. I haven't had any issues since. In my female class I had two girls that would talk about the other girls in the class. I spoke with them and asked them to keep their opinions to themselves because others were offended by their comments. They understood and it has not been an issue. I also have an openly gay female but there are no problems. I agree with you that teacher selection is the key. I have great classroom management and know how to build relationships with students. My students tell me all the time how they love coming to my class and they have learned so much this year. I spoke with my site supervisor about if we extend same sex classes like I want to, we would have to be selective in who we choose to teach those classes. I think it is easier for me because I am a young female and the males are focused visually while the females see me as an older sister. My students confide in me about all kinds of situations from relationship drama to pregnancy scares to miscarriages. I feel like a counselor some days but am glad to do it because they work that much harder for me because they know I care about their well being.

      Delete
  10. Looks great! I would be interested to see your findings. It would also be interested to look at how it affects different age groups. Is it better at middle school versus high school or even elementary. You have put in a lot a thought to this and I know you will have great results.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would love to see the effects in other grades. That would be interesting to see which age group benefits better. Thanks for posting

      Delete
  11. Jamie, when I was in college I observed a same sex elementary school class of African American boys. It was a program that was supposed to have an African American male to teach the boys. Unfortunately, they did not have enough African American male teachers available, so an experienced African American female taught the boys. It was a self contained homeroom. I believe they were 2nd graders. Needless to say, she had her hands FULL. She handled them, but they were quite a bunch. Do you think the gender of the teacher could affect the outcome of your study in any way? I only thought about that because of my experience.
    This is a very interesting topic of study. Your results are worth sharing. PLEASE do!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That sounds really interesting. I would love to observe a same sex school. I think the gender of the teacher matters but I also think the age of the students matters as well. I believe that being a young female teacher has really helped me with my same sex classes. I couldn't imagine teaching 2nd grades, elementary is not my calling but I believe in that situation an African American male would have been a better choice. To make the master schedule easier, when I teach a male class a white male teacher is teaching a female class. From talking with students and observing, it seems that my students respond to me better than they do to him. The issue that we run across at our school is students equate liking a teacher to being able to learn.

      Delete
  12. My school has a few same sex classes at the middle school level. I am not familiar with the academic success of these classes but I know they had many disciple problems. Your plan looks well thought out and I will be waiting to see what success you are able to gleam at the HS level.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I have also always wondered what the effect of same sex classes would be on test results. I am looking forward to following your research. Sharing your findings with your colleagues is a great idea, I know they would be interested. Good luck!

    ReplyDelete